As Pigeon Boss, I often get asked the same question. “Why do auctions on pigeon sites vanish the moment they close?” And not always in a neutral tone. “What are they trying to hide?” or “Why can’t I still see what that pigeon ended up selling for?”
I get it. These are fair questions. In a sport where trust is everything, people want clarity. Transparency. Reassurance that things are run properly. So I decided to dig deep and find out what’s really going on. Not based on assumptions, but on facts.
What I found is this. Most of the time, there is no shady business at all. In fact, the reasons behind this practice are solid. That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t keep asking questions. But it does mean the answers are often more reasonable than we think.
Technical reasons
Auction platforms are built for speed, clarity, and stability. With dozens or even hundreds of lots running at once, the site needs to stay fast and clean. Visitors need to focus on current auctions, not get distracted by past results.
That’s why auctions that have ended are automatically hidden from public view. They are still accessible to those involved, but the rest of the world no longer sees them. This keeps the system light and avoids confusion or mistakes with expired bids.
But let’s be honest. This also limits learning. Young fanciers or curious buyers can’t look up how a certain bloodline performed. That’s a missed chance to grow and understand the market better.
Commercial strategy
There is also a business logic at play. Top auction platforms like Amazing-Wings, PIPA, Herbots, and GPS-Auctions operate in a competitive world. High-value birds, big buyers, and high stakes are part of their daily routine. Privacy and control matter.
Buyers often prefer to stay anonymous. Not because they are hiding something, but because they don’t want calls from dealers or other fanciers. And sellers sometimes want to protect their name or reputation if a sale didn’t go as expected.
By removing auctions right after closing, platforms control the narrative. They decide which results to highlight and which to keep in-house. That can feel selective, and it is. But it’s also how they protect their clients and their brand.
There’s another angle too. Studies show that bidders are often more comfortable and even bid higher when they know results won’t be made public. It removes pressure. It boosts confidence. And yes, it often raises final prices.
So is it clever? Definitely. Is it sneaky? That depends on how much openness you think the sport needs.
My Boss Tip: clear out the cupboard and switch to Berger Products Today
Good, Better, Best | Pigeon Boss Approved
Legal responsibilities
There is also the law. The GDPR in Europe puts strict limits on what personal data can be shown and for how long. During an auction, usernames, flags, and bid histories might be visible. But once it’s over, that becomes a legal gray area.
Auction sites are playing it safe. By removing that data from public view, they avoid privacy risks and protect their users. This isn’t hiding. This is compliance. And it’s the kind of careful handling you’d expect from a professional organization.
What about transparency
The criticism is still valid. If nobody can see what pigeons actually sold for, how do we learn? How do we track the value of a line or the demand for a certain strain?
Maybe it’s time for auction sites to rethink the balance. A short-term archive with key details. Prices, pedigrees, ring numbers. No names or flags. Just enough to give insight without risking privacy.
That would help make the sport more transparent and educational for everyone.
The sport is cleaner than you think
Here’s the real message. Most of the time, auctions going offline is not about secrets. It’s about protection. It’s about privacy. It’s about keeping things professional and secure.
And yes, sometimes it’s also about strategy. But that’s not the same as dishonesty. Most people in this sport are here for the right reasons. They buy with passion. They sell with pride. They care about the pigeons, and about doing things right.
Let’s stay curious. Let’s ask questions. But let’s also assume good intent unless proven otherwise.
That’s what keeps this sport strong.
Jan de Wijs
The Pigeon Boss
